Tom Rosenthal
Insurance Appraisal Umpire
Alba, TX
Experienced, Professional, Timely
About
Decades of building experience. Insurance adjuster, Public adjuster, Building consultant, Appraiser, Contractor, subject matter expert are all roles and functions that I have participated in and held positions in. The traits that I look for in an umpire are: Consistent in their approach, the definitions of damage and causation that can be relied on from claim to claim. Applicable knowledge, an umpire that understands AND can explain their observation and why they rule the way they do. Timeliness; the amount of time it takes for an umpire to render a decision has much more to do with work ethic than workload. There are many people waiting for the results of an appraisal, an umpire dragging out a decision is unprofessional and immoral. I have worked for both sides. I write estimates today exactly as I did from day 1. I consider damage that is visible and demonstratable. An umpire's role is to consider the differences in the 2 appraiser's position, not to create his own. It is up to the appraisers to introduce documents, experts and relevant facts, not the umpire. Damages should be considered if it is related to the claim, policy language is irrelevant in appraisal.