Find a property appraisal umpire both sides can agree on.
A quick introduction 1 min
See how it works
Search independent insurance appraisal umpires by state, loss type, credentials, fee expectations, and turnaround — then build a clean shareable candidate list for the opposing appraiser.
Are you an appraisal umpire? Create your public profile.
Search the directory
Start broad. Refine on the directory page and choose 2–5 candidates for a shared list.
No account required to view profiles or open a shared list.
Most-endorsed public profiles
The four highest ranking scores appear here. Each thumbs up adds 1 point; each assignment endorsed by both participating appraisers adds 5 points. The same score orders state and other filtered searches. No stars or written reviews.
An endorsement records the participants’ recommendations. Property Claim Umpires does not verify the fairness or legal outcome of an award.
Turn a deadlock into a short list.
The shareable-list flow is the site’s differentiator. Compare candidates, pick the ones you’d accept, and send the other side one clean read-only link.
Search by jurisdiction and loss type
Filter for umpires who serve the state and understand the claim category — hurricane, hail, water, fire, commercial, large loss, and more.
Select 2–5 acceptable candidates
Compare fees, turnaround, credentials, neutrality indicators, direct contact details, and CVs without digging through giant cards.
Send a clean read-only link
Email the opposing appraiser a permanent or time-limited URL. They review the same candidates without creating an account.
Find umpires by jurisdiction.
Click any state to see umpires serving that jurisdiction.
Modern filters, not form chores.
These chips link to a pre-filtered directory search. Easier to scan than a lone dropdown.
Transparent by design.
Not a lead marketplace. A clean professional roster with enough context to make a defensible selection.
Organic rank is not sold
Sponsored placements, if added later, will be visibly labeled and kept separate from organic ranking.
Thumbs up, kept simple
Recommend a professional with one thumbs up. You can remove your vote. No star ratings or written reviews.
Direct contact only
Call or email the umpire directly. No lead-broker contact form sitting in the middle.
Shareable shortlist
A neutral read-only link makes it easy for both sides to review the same candidates.
What is an insurance appraisal umpire?
A neutral tie-breaker
When the two appraisers cannot agree on the amount of loss, the umpire helps resolve the dollar-value dispute.
Not a judge or arbitrator
The umpire decides valuation issues — not coverage, bad faith, or extra-contractual damages.
Competent and impartial
Profiles surface experience, credentials, fees, and party-mix indicators so you can evaluate before agreement.
Ready to propose candidates?
Search the directory, choose the umpires you would accept, and send one clean link to the opposing appraiser.